⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways
- Cleaning can permanently damage coins: Even gentle cleaning involves some risk. Never attempt to make an old coin look new, especially if it could have collector value.
- Start with plain running water: Josh demonstrates removing loose dirt from ordinary, face-value coins without scrubbing their surfaces.
- Watch for green corrosion: Verdigris on copper coins can indicate chemical deterioration and underlying surface damage that ordinary rinsing cannot reverse.
- Know when to stop: Pat coins dry rather than rubbing them. If corrosion remains on a potentially valuable find, consult a professional numismatic conservator before attempting further treatment.
Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights
[00:25] — Why Cleaning Buried Coins Can Ruin Them
Josh begins by explaining why cleaning is controversial among coin collectors. Removing enough dirt to identify a coin is different from polishing it to improve its appearance, and the latter can destroy the original surfaces collectors value.
[01:28] — The Gentlest Way to Remove Dirt
Using a 1964-D Lincoln cent, a 1971 Lincoln cent, and a 1997 Philadelphia Jefferson nickel recovered from his backyard, Josh demonstrates rinsing loose debris away with running water. He emphasizes gently patting the coins dry, since rubbing with a towel can leave permanent scratches and hairlines.
[02:23] — Verdigris, Corrosion & Professional Conservation
A green spot near the lettering on one Lincoln cent introduces the problem of verdigris, a form of copper corrosion. Josh explains why removing the visible deposit may not repair the underlying metal and discusses professional conservation for valuable coins, including its expense and uncertain results.
Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice
“you can’t make an old coin look new without damaging it”
That observation gets to the heart of an important distinction: cleaning a coin for identification is not the same as improving its appearance. When metal detecting turns up a dirt-covered penny or nickel, the immediate temptation is to scrub away decades of grime. But the original surface, including its natural toning and patina, is part of the coin’s history. Removing it can make a collectible coin less desirable, even when the result looks brighter.
The three backyard finds in this demonstration are ordinary circulating coins, making them reasonable examples for showing basic cleaning precautions. Josh’s approach is deliberately conservative: rinse loose material away, avoid rubbing, and stop when additional treatment would introduce unnecessary risk. Before touching a potentially valuable discovery, review the reasons not to clean collectible coins.
Corrosion presents a different challenge. Verdigris can conceal permanent damage, and removing the green material does not restore missing metal. Professional conservation may be appropriate for an expensive find, but its cost can exceed the value of an ordinary coin. Understanding the difference between a collectible and a cull coin helps determine whether further treatment is worthwhile.
Coin Preservation & Metal Detecting Reference
Coins buried in soil encounter moisture, minerals, oxygen, and other environmental contaminants. Copper-based coins are particularly susceptible to surface changes, including green corrosion deposits commonly called verdigris. Depending on the burial environment, these reactions can alter or permanently damage the metal long before a detectorist discovers the coin.
Unlike loose soil, corrosion is not simply dirt waiting to be washed away. A coin can retain dark toning or green deposits after rinsing and still be recognizable. The objective should be to preserve the surviving surface, not recreate a freshly minted appearance. The following reference summarizes the three actual coins demonstrated in the video and the preservation issues Josh identifies.
| Coin | Metal & Cleaning Considerations |
| 1964-D Lincoln Cent | 95% copper alloy; original surfaces and patina should be preserved. |
| 1971 Lincoln Cent | 95% copper alloy; green verdigris is visible near the motto in the demonstration. |
| 1997-P Jefferson Nickel | 75% copper, 25% nickel; loose dirt can be rinsed away without abrasive rubbing. |
| Recommended First Step | For common face-value finds, use plain water to remove loose dirt and gently pat dry. Do not scrub. |
| When to Seek Professional Help | For potentially valuable coins with persistent contamination or corrosion, consult a numismatic conservator before further treatment. |