Start Here

Values

Buying & Selling

Rare U.S. Coins

How To's

Are Quarters With No Ridges ERROR Coins? What Are They WORTH?!

Video Summary & Key Takeaways

⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways

  • Three possible causes: A quarter can lose its visible edge reeding through post-Mint damage, extensive circulation wear, or a genuine broadstrike mint error.
  • Look at the rim: Broadstrike quarters typically have an expanded diameter, a thinner profile, and a weak or missing normal raised rim.
  • Real-world value: Most worn or damaged smooth-edge quarters are worth 25 cents. Josh demonstrates a genuine broadstrike quarter that sold for $222 at Heritage Auctions in September 2020.
  • Inspection tip: Examine the rim with a magnifier and compare the coin’s diameter and thickness with a normal quarter before assuming you’ve discovered an error.

Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights

[01:33] — Why Some Quarters Have Smooth Edges

Josh begins by examining quarters that appear to have no edge reeding whatsoever. One example has a thick, rounded edge caused by post-Mint damage, potentially from tumbling inside a clothes dryer, while other quarters have simply experienced enough circulation wear to obscure their original ridges. Neither situation automatically indicates a valuable mint error, even when the coin looks dramatically different from an ordinary Washington quarter.

[04:43] — How Genuine Broadstrike Quarter Errors Happen

The video then explores the striking process and explains the role of the retaining collar inside a coin press. Normally, this collar controls the planchet’s expansion and impresses the familiar reeded edge onto a quarter. When a quarter is struck outside its collar, the metal can spread beyond its intended diameter, creating a broadstrike error with a flattened appearance and missing edge reeding.

[06:28] — Broadstrike Quarter Values And Identification

Josh presents a genuine broadstrike quarter that realized $222 at Heritage Auctions in September 2020, illustrating the difference between collectible striking errors and ordinary damage. He demonstrates why collectors should evaluate the entire coin rather than concentrating only on the smooth edge. An expanded diameter, reduced thickness, and an abnormal rim can provide important evidence that a quarter was struck without its retaining collar.

J

Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice

“But the way you could tell this error (broadstrike) from these regular strike quarters here that just have some damage or wear is again… look at it.”

One of the most important lessons in coin collecting is that an unusual appearance doesn’t necessarily mean a valuable error. A quarter with a completely smooth edge can look extraordinary, especially when compared with the sharply reeded edges we’re accustomed to seeing. But the real question is whether that unusual feature originated during the minting process or developed afterward. The distinction is essential when identifying post-Mint damage versus genuine mint errors.

For collectors searching through pocket change, the best approach is to examine several characteristics together. Check the edge, but also inspect the raised rim, the coin’s overall shape, and the relationship between its diameter and thickness. A broadstrike quarter is usually wider and thinner because the metal expanded without the normal restriction of the striking collar. By contrast, a dryer-damaged quarter may have a thick, rolled-over edge that actually makes its diameter smaller.

Before spending money on professional authentication, compare your find with documented broadstrike coin error examples. Take clear photographs of both faces and the edge, and avoid cleaning or altering the coin. Good documentation and careful comparison can save money while helping you recognize an authentic minting mistake.

Historical Context & Mint Specifications

Reeded edges have been an important feature of American coinage for more than two centuries. Historically, edge treatments helped reveal attempts to remove precious metal from gold and silver coins. Although modern circulating quarters are made primarily from copper-nickel clad material rather than silver, their familiar reeded edges remain part of the traditional design.

Modern quarter reeding is formed during the striking process by a specially machined collar surrounding the planchet. When that collar is absent or fails to contain the metal properly, the struck coin can spread outward instead of retaining its standard dimensions. This explains why a genuine broadstrike quarter differs from one whose reeding disappeared through ordinary wear or damage. Broadstrikes are production mistakes, not intentionally issued varieties, so there is no standard mintage figure for them. Their collectible value depends on the specific error, condition, eye appeal, and market demand.

Series / DenominationWashington Quarter / 25 Cents
Mint Mark / Key DatesVarious dates and mints; broadstrikes are striking errors, not date-specific varieties
Composition & WeightModern clad quarters: copper-nickel outer layers over a copper core; standard weight 5.67 grams
Original MintageNo separate official mintage for broadstrike errors; varies by date and mint
Designer / EngraverJohn Flanagan (original Washington obverse); reverse designs vary by issue