Start Here

Values

Buying & Selling

Rare U.S. Coins

How To's

Should America STOP Making Pennies? (One Collector’s Opinion!)

Video Summary & Key Takeaways

⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways

  • Production vs. circulation: Ending production of new pennies does not mean existing one-cent coins immediately disappear or lose their spending value.
  • Why production is ending: Josh cites an early-2025 manufacturing cost of approximately 3.9 cents for each one-cent coin, nearly four times its face value.
  • Consumer impact: Cash purchases may be rounded to the nearest nickel when exact change is unavailable, while electronic transactions can continue to be calculated to the cent.
  • Collector opportunity: Increased public interest could encourage more penny searching, but an ordinary circulated cent will not automatically become valuable. Inspect dates, mintmarks, condition, and recognized varieties before setting coins aside.

Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights

[00:23] — How One Wheat Penny Started a Lifelong Collection

Josh opens his Lincoln cent albums and recalls finding a 1941 wheat penny in his allowance change when he was 11 years old. That discovery helped launch a collecting journey that eventually included the famous key-date Lincoln cents, major doubled-die varieties, and modern issues. His personal collection illustrates why ending production means much more to collectors than simply retiring an inexpensive coin.

[06:51] — Why Making Pennies Became So Expensive

Producing a one-cent coin for nearly four cents raises an obvious economic question: Should the government continue manufacturing money at such a loss? Josh recognizes the financial argument for discontinuation while explaining why the penny retains cultural and historical importance. His discussion distinguishes the government’s production costs from the personal value collectors attach to the denomination.

[08:30] — Cash Rounding, Consumers & Future Penny Values

Josh examines how removing newly manufactured pennies from commerce could affect everyday cash transactions, especially for Americans who depend heavily on physical currency. He also considers whether heightened awareness might bring new collectors into the hobby and increase demand for certain Lincoln cents. Importantly, he presents future price increases as a possibility, not a certainty.

J

Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice

“But whatever the case may be, the end of the penny does mark the end of an era”

For someone who began collecting Lincoln cents as a child, the disappearance of newly produced pennies represents a major turning point. But collectors should distinguish the end of production from the end of collectibility. Billions of existing cents can remain in collections, coin jars, and circulation long after the Mint stops striking new examples. Their abundance means that ordinary circulated pennies are unlikely to become rare simply because production has ended.

The practical approach is to organize what you already own. Build a date-and-mintmark collection, examine older wheat cents, and learn to identify genuine doubled-die varieties rather than assuming every unusual-looking coin is valuable. Review the history and little-known facts about U.S. pennies to better understand what makes particular issues interesting.

One especially important distinction is between sentimental value and market value. A childhood discovery might be priceless to its owner while remaining worth only a few cents commercially. Collectors interested in the changing denomination should also explore what ending penny production means for collectors. Preserve meaningful examples carefully, avoid cleaning coins, and let established rarity, condition, and collector demand guide purchasing decisions.

Historical Context & Mint Specifications

The United States has issued one-cent coins since the early years of federal coinage, with Abraham Lincoln first appearing on the denomination in 1909. Lincoln wheat cents, Lincoln Memorial cents, the four 2009 Bicentennial reverses, and the Union Shield design each represent distinct chapters in American numismatic history. For generations, these inexpensive coins introduced children and adults to collecting through pocket change and coin rolls.

The decision to end penny production reflects the growing gap between the coin’s face value and its manufacturing cost. The video’s early-2025 discussion captures the uncertainty surrounding the Mint’s final production plans and the potential effects on cash commerce. Although new production can stop, existing coins do not automatically become scarce. Collector demand, original mintages, survival rates, and condition will continue to determine which pennies command premiums.

Series / DenominationLincoln Cent / $0.01
Mint Marks / Key DatesP (typically no mintmark), D, S; 1909-S VDB, 1914-D, 1931-S and other notable dates and varieties
Composition & WeightModern cents: copper-plated zinc, 2.5 g; traditional bronze cents: approximately 3.11 g
Original MintageVaries by year and mint; billions of Lincoln cents produced across the series
Designer / EngraverVictor David Brenner (Lincoln obverse); various reverse designers