Start Here

Values

Buying & Selling

Rare U.S. Coins

How To's

How To GRADE Coins Yourself To Determine VALUE [Coin Condition 101]

Video Summary & Key Takeaways

⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways

  • Start With ANA Standards: Compare your coin against published photographs and descriptions of established coin grades instead of guessing from its overall appearance.
  • Inspect High Points: On Lincoln cents, check the cheek, jaw, beard, hair, and reverse design for evidence of circulation wear.
  • Understand the Grades: Josh demonstrates About Uncirculated (AU55) and Extremely Fine (XF45) using actual 1977 and 1957-D pennies from his collection.
  • Grade Conservatively: A coin’s condition influences its potential value. Use good lighting, magnification, and comparison examples before assigning a grade.

Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights

[00:10] — Professional Coin Grading vs. Grading at Home

Josh begins with certified examples of valuable doubled die Lincoln cents encapsulated by professional grading services NGC and PCGS. He explains how collectors can evaluate their own raw, unencapsulated coins without immediately paying for professional certification.

[00:50] — Using the ANA Coin Grading Standards Book

The American Numismatic Association grading guide provides illustrated examples of coins at different preservation levels. Josh demonstrates how to compare a coin’s remaining design details, wear patterns, and overall appearance against the reference photographs and written descriptions.

[02:29] — Grading a 1977 No-Mintmark Lincoln Penny

Josh examines Lincoln’s facial features and the Memorial reverse, weighing the visible circulation wear against the ANA’s AU grading descriptions. Although he initially considers AU50, his closer comparison leads him to assign a conservative AU55 grade.

[05:21] — Comparing Another 1977 Lincoln Cent

A second 1977 penny retains traces of mint luster and considerable detail in Lincoln’s cheek and beard. Comparing it with the previous example, Josh concludes that AU55 is also an appropriate grade for this coin.

[05:50] — Why the 1957-D Wheat Penny Grades XF45

The final example is a 1957-D Lincoln Wheat cent showing more wear than the two Memorial cents. Josh compares Lincoln’s facial details and the definition of the reverse wheat stalks, ultimately assigning XF45 while acknowledging that another collector might reasonably choose XF40.

J

Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice

“I would rather have a coin that is graded lower than it actually is, than the opposite.”

Conservative grading is one of the most useful habits a beginning collector can develop. When two neighboring grades seem plausible, don’t automatically choose the higher one because the coin looks attractive. Instead, compare the specific wear points identified in the ANA standards. The difference between XF45 and AU55 isn’t simply how old or shiny a penny looks; it involves the extent and location of wear, along with surviving design details and luster.

The 1977 Memorial cents and 1957-D Wheat cent illustrate another important lesson: you must examine the appropriate design. The ANA descriptions for wheat stalks don’t directly apply to a Memorial reverse. Compare the features that actually appear on your coin, and inspect both sides before making your decision. Our guide to determining U.S. coin grades provides additional reference information.

Finally, remember that your estimated grade is an informed opinion, not a professional certification. A coin’s value also depends on rarity, collector demand, surface quality, and possible damage. Before buying or selling, review the fundamentals of coin grading and condition. Practice with inexpensive circulated coins first, and never clean a coin to make it appear to be in better condition.

Coin Grading Standards & Reference Guide

Coin grading developed as collectors and dealers sought consistent ways to describe preservation and distinguish heavily circulated pieces from nearly unworn examples. The widely used Sheldon numerical scale runs from 1 through 70, with higher numbers representing better states of preservation. The ANA’s published grading standards help collectors interpret these numbers through illustrated examples and descriptions of wear.

In this demonstration, Josh applies those standards to ordinary Lincoln cents. The emphasis is on judging actual physical condition rather than assuming that a particular date or mintmark makes a coin valuable. These grading terms apply broadly to U.S. numismatics, although the exact diagnostic details vary by coin design.

Grade / AbbreviationWhat It Means
Good (G4)Heavily worn, with major design elements remaining identifiable.
Very Fine (VF20–VF35)Moderate wear, with substantial major design details remaining.
Extremely Fine (XF40–XF45)Light wear on higher design points; most details remain sharp.
About Uncirculated (AU50–AU58)Only slight circulation wear, often with some remaining mint luster.
Mint State (MS60–MS70)No circulation wear; surface marks, luster, and other qualities determine the numerical grade.

Collector tip: EF and XF are interchangeable abbreviations for Extremely Fine. A grade such as XF45 represents a specific point on the numerical grading scale, not an estimate of a coin’s dollar value.