Start Here

Values

Buying & Selling

Rare U.S. Coins

How To's

How to Clean Coins with VINEGAR (Pennies & Quarters)

Video Summary & Key Takeaways

⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways

  • Vinegar changes coin surfaces: A two-hour soak visibly lightened the submerged half of a clad quarter, but it did not restore the coin to its original condition.
  • Pennies react differently: A brief vinegar treatment produced little visible change on Josh’s dark 1999-D Lincoln cent.
  • Baking soda is abrasive: Rubbing the penny with baking soda removed some surface discoloration, but this can also damage its original finish.
  • Collector warning: Never experiment with valuable, rare, proof, or collectible coins. Cleaning can permanently reduce their numismatic value.

Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights

[00:10] Why Collectors Should Never Clean Valuable Coins

Josh begins with an important warning: cleaning a coin can damage its surface and lower its collector value. He explains why the naturally developed chocolate-brown patina on an older Lincoln cent is desirable rather than something that needs to be scrubbed away.

[02:12] What Happens After Soaking a Quarter in Vinegar?

After partially submerging a copper-nickel clad quarter in vinegar for approximately two hours, Josh compares the treated and untreated portions. The submerged half looks noticeably lighter, demonstrating that vinegar can alter surface discoloration without necessarily making the coin look new or restoring its original appearance.

[05:23] Vinegar and Baking Soda on a Lincoln Penny

Josh tests a dark 1999-D penny and finds that a short vinegar treatment alone makes little visible difference. Adding baking soda and rubbing the surface produces a lighter appearance, but the experiment also illustrates why abrasive cleaning is particularly risky for collectible copper coins.

J

Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice

“I love chocolate brown, old Lincoln cents. Those are the way they should look.”

That observation gets to the heart of a common misunderstanding about coin collecting: a brighter coin isn’t automatically a better coin. Copper naturally develops brown coloration as its surface reacts with the environment. On older Lincoln cents, that appearance can be entirely appropriate. Removing the coloration with vinegar or abrasives may make a penny look lighter, but it cannot recreate the original mint surface that collectors value.

Before treating an unfamiliar penny or quarter, identify its date, mintmark, and potential collector significance. A seemingly ordinary coin could have a valuable variety or other characteristic that deserves closer examination. Our guide to identifying cleaned coins explains why surface alterations matter when evaluating condition and originality.

Another important distinction is the difference between removing loose contamination and chemically changing a coin’s surface. Even a soft cloth can leave microscopic hairlines if rubbed across a coin. For coins worth preserving, prevention, careful handling, and appropriate storage are usually better choices than attempting to improve their appearance. Review our coin cleaning precautions before considering any treatment.

Coin Cleaning Science & Experiment Results

Vinegar contains acetic acid, which can react with certain surface compounds on metal coins. Copper pennies often develop oxide and other surface layers over time, while copper-nickel clad quarters can acquire discoloration from circulation and environmental exposure. These changes are not necessarily harmful deposits that should be removed; some are part of the coin’s natural aging process.

In this demonstration, Josh uses an ordinary clad quarter and a 1999-D Lincoln cent rather than collectible rarities. His results show why vinegar is an unpredictable cleaning treatment: exposure time, metal composition, surface condition, and additional abrasion can all influence the outcome. The experiment does not test a silver coin, and its results should not be assumed to apply to silver collectibles.

ExperimentObserved Result / Collector Consideration
Clad quarter / 2-hour vinegar soakThe submerged portion appeared several shades lighter than the untreated portion.
1999-D penny / brief vinegar exposureOnly a small visible change after approximately two minutes.
Penny / baking soda abrasionSurface discoloration was removed and the coin looked lighter, but abrasion risks permanent damage.
Rinsing and dryingJosh demonstrates patting dry rather than rubbing to avoid adding hairlines.
Final collector recommendationDo not use vinegar, baking soda, or abrasive cleaning on collectible coins.