⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways
- Does toothpaste clean coins? Yes. Its abrasive ingredients can remove dark surface discoloration and make a penny appear brighter, but they can also permanently damage its surface.
- The demonstration coin: Josh uses an ordinary 2019-D Lincoln Memorial successor, a Lincoln Shield cent, with a copper-plated zinc composition. It is not a valuable collectible being restored.
- Original patina matters: Collectors often prefer natural toning and original surfaces. A bright, artificially cleaned coin may be worth less than an untouched example.
- Inspect before cleaning: Check the date, mintmark, condition, and possible varieties with a magnifier before doing anything that could alter a coin’s surface.
Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights
[00:12] — Why You Shouldn’t Clean Coins With Toothpaste
Josh begins with an important warning: cleaning coins can permanently reduce their collectible value. Toothpaste contains abrasives that can remove the outermost metal along with discoloration, leaving microscopic scratches and altering the original finish. He explains why a coin’s natural patina may be desirable even when it appears dark or unattractive to someone unfamiliar with collecting.
[01:34] — Demonstrating Toothpaste Cleaning On A 2019-D Penny
Using an ordinary 2019-D Lincoln cent, Josh demonstrates how rubbing toothpaste across the coin gradually lightens its darkened surface. He explains that the abrasive action reaches into the design’s small recesses while also removing some original surface material. This is a demonstration of what toothpaste does to a coin, not a recommended conservation technique for collectible pennies.
[05:07] — Rinsing, Drying & The Final Results
After rubbing the penny with toothpaste, Josh rinses it under cold water and gently pats it dry with a soft white cloth. The finished coin looks lighter, brighter, and more reflective than before. However, the visual improvement comes at the expense of its original surface, demonstrating why a successful cosmetic cleaning is not necessarily a good outcome for a coin collector.
Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice
“And my answer typically is: YOU DON’T. Because cleaning coins can actually ruin their value”
One of the most important lessons in this demonstration is that a coin can look better to a casual observer while becoming less desirable to an experienced collector. The 2019-D penny used in the video has developed dark surface discoloration. That appearance might seem like something worth correcting, but original color and surface texture are important parts of a coin’s condition and history.
Before attempting to remove discoloration, determine whether a coin has any collectible value. Examine its date, mintmark, design details, and potential errors. If it is an older coin, an uncirculated example, or anything potentially scarce, leave its surface alone. Our guide explaining why you should not clean coins covers the risks and appropriate alternatives.
Another important distinction is the difference between removing loose surface contamination and polishing away original metal or toning. Toothpaste is an abrasive cleaner, not a professional coin conservation treatment. Its apparent success can leave behind the very evidence that makes a coin less appealing to knowledgeable buyers. Learning how to identify cleaned coins is useful whether you’re evaluating coins already in your collection or considering a purchase.
Historical Context & Mint Specifications
The Lincoln cent has been produced since 1909, making it one of America’s most familiar circulating coins. The 2019-D penny in Josh’s demonstration belongs to the Lincoln Shield cent series, introduced in 2010. Its reverse features a Union shield, while its obverse retains Victor David Brenner’s portrait of Abraham Lincoln.
Unlike early Lincoln cents, which were predominantly copper, modern circulating pennies have a zinc core covered with a thin copper plating. This composition has been used since 1982. The thin plating is one reason abrasive cleaning deserves particular caution: rubbing and polishing can compromise the coin’s original surface. Although billions of modern cents were produced for everyday commerce, original condition still matters when collectors evaluate individual examples.
| Series / Denomination | 2019 Lincoln Shield Cent / $0.01 |
| Mint Mark / Date | D — Denver Mint / 2019 |
| Composition & Weight | 97.5% zinc, 2.5% copper / 2.50 grams |
| Original Mintage | 3,473,600,000 (2019-D cents) |
| Designer / Engraver | Victor D. Brenner (obverse); Lyndall Bass (reverse design) |