Start Here

Values

Buying & Selling

Rare U.S. Coins

How To's

Cleaning Coins With BAKING SODA & VINEGAR (See How Well It Works!)

Video Summary & Key Takeaways

⚡ Quick Collector Takeaways

  • Does it work? Yes. Vinegar and baking soda can remove visible discoloration from common pennies, nickels, and quarters, as Josh demonstrates in real time.
  • The major warning: A coin that looks cleaner isn’t necessarily better. Abrasive cleaning can permanently damage its original surface and reduce collector value.
  • Different coins, different results: The 1967 Lincoln cent lightens gradually, while a discolored nickel responds quickly. The South Carolina quarter also becomes noticeably brighter.
  • Before you experiment: Check the coin’s date, mintmark, and potential collector value first. Josh uses inexpensive, face-value coins for this demonstration—not valuable collectibles.

Video Breakdown & Chapter Highlights

[00:00] — Why Josh Doesn’t Recommend Cleaning Coins

Josh begins by explaining why he generally advises collectors against cleaning coins, even when they look dirty or tarnished. He selects ordinary pennies, a nickel, and quarters worth little more than face value to demonstrate a popular household cleaning method without risking collectible coins.

[02:09] — Cleaning a 1967 Penny With Baking Soda

After a brief vinegar soak, Josh scrubs a heavily darkened 1967 Lincoln cent with baking soda. The raised portions of Lincoln’s portrait, the lettering, and the rim begin to lighten, but the results also illustrate how abrasive cleaning changes a coin’s surface rather than simply removing loose dirt.

[04:32] — Nickel and Quarter Cleaning Results

Josh tests a greenish, environmentally discolored nickel and then a South Carolina State Quarter. Both respond visibly to baking soda scrubbing, particularly the nickel. By the end, he concludes that the method can be effective at changing a coin’s appearance while repeating his warning that the cleaned coins are now damaged from a collector’s perspective.

J

Josh’s Director’s Cut: Practical Numismatic Advice

“Baking soda, as you know, is a very abrasive agent.”

That observation is the most important lesson in this demonstration. Baking soda can make a dark, discolored coin appear brighter because rubbing it against the metal removes surface material and deposits. Unfortunately, the same abrasive action can leave fine scratches and disturb the original finish. What looks like an improvement to someone who wants shiny pocket change can be permanent damage to a coin collector.

The distinction matters especially with older copper cents. Their natural brown coloration can develop over decades, and removing it does not restore the original Mint surface. A cleaned coin may look unusually bright while showing unnatural color, hairlines, or inconsistent surfaces under magnification. Our guide to identifying cleaned coins explains why these signs matter when evaluating a purchase.

Before cleaning any coin, identify it and determine whether it has collectible value. Even a coin that appears common might have a desirable date, mintmark, or variety. If preservation is your goal, leaving its original surfaces alone is generally the safest decision. See our advice on why you shouldn’t clean collectible coins before trying a household remedy. A little dirt is often far less damaging than an irreversible cleaning experiment.

The Science Behind Vinegar and Baking Soda Coin Cleaning

Vinegar contains acetic acid, which can react with certain surface deposits and corrosion products on coins. Baking soda, or sodium bicarbonate, is mildly alkaline and acts as an abrasive when rubbed against metal. Mixing vinegar and baking soda also produces carbon dioxide bubbles as the acid and base react, but the fizzing itself doesn’t guarantee effective cleaning. The two substances partially neutralize each other, so their combined action is not necessarily more effective than using them separately.

Coin composition also affects the results. The copper-rich 1967 Lincoln cent in Josh’s demonstration behaves differently from the copper-nickel Jefferson nickel and clad State Quarter. These coins have different surface characteristics, and exposure to acidic solutions or abrasive rubbing can affect each one differently. The following comparison explains what the demonstration shows and why a brighter appearance shouldn’t be confused with proper conservation.

Coin / MethodObserved Result & Collector Risk
1967 Lincoln CentGradual lightening of the dark copper surface. Abrasive rubbing can leave scratches and unnatural coloration.
Jefferson NickelRapid removal of visible yellow-green discoloration. The improved appearance does not establish that the original surface is undamaged.
South Carolina State QuarterVisible brightening after several swipes. Scrubbing can damage the coin’s copper-nickel clad surface.
Vinegar SoakAcidic exposure can loosen some surface deposits, but it may also alter or damage coin surfaces.
Baking Soda ScrubbingRemoves visible discoloration through abrasion, with a risk of permanent hairlines and loss of original surface characteristics.

The collector’s bottom line: This experiment demonstrates that household ingredients can visibly clean common coins—not that they can safely conserve collectible ones. Professional numismatic conservation and ordinary household cleaning are very different processes. When a coin might be valuable, preserve its existing surface and seek qualified advice before attempting treatment.